PROS: The quickest way to go and very inexpensive. The Asian builders are paid $2 or so per day. If it takes 8 weeks to build a plane, then that's only $80 or so. That's cheap! If you do have an accident, then repair parts are fairly easy to come by. Most people cannot build an airplane as well as an Asian ARF. The quality is going up and up all the time, so they are a great way to go. I greatly prefer ARF planes over kits. Some kits are better than others.
CONS: The quality varies from manufacturer to manufacturer. Quality is getting better all the time. Chinese planes are the most advanced followed by Thailand and then followed by South America. Now, having said that, the Thailand produced Composite ARF planes are a higher quality plane, probably due to the owner living in the shop, while importers who aren't on the production floor on a daily basis have less control on quality. Thailand is not as developed as China, so there are fewer NC machines and the aluminum heat treating is not up to the standards of China (though Chinese aluminum is pretty bad), much less the US. The adhesives used now are much better than before, the wood is better, the machining is better, the assembly is better, the paint is better, and the hardware is better. The covering now used in many planes is Ultracote which is FAR superior to the "Chinacote" or "Procote" or whatever they call it. The Comp ARF planes are pretty good quality but I think that the 3W planes have much higher quality paint jobs. The paint jobs on the Comp ARF planes are done in the mold so it saves weight but the seams are evident as they can't be sanded. The 3W planes are painted out of the mold, so the seams are sanded and the colors shine better. The paint jobs are beautiful, but alas, they are much heavier. I would rather have a Comp ARF plane than a 3W plane because of the weight savings.
CONSTANT QUALITY IMPROVEMENTS - TBM provides feedback to the manufacturers for improvements which are being made on an ongoing basis. Each batch of airplanes are better than the last. Constant improvements are the nature of the giant scale industry.
ABOVE AVERAGE ARF PLANES: SD-Models are the best value in a plane in my opinion. They have the lowest pricing, and offer a light yet strong and good flying plane, though their instruction manuals could be better. They boast the lowest wing loadings in most cases, and thus they fly very light. Garrett Morrison is one of the best pilots in the world and he is helping out tremendously with the design and testing of the new planes, though Garrett is no longer associated with the company. They use Ultracote. They should be one to compare others against.
Aeroworks has their new QB or "Quick Build" line. These are the fastest building planes by far at this time. The hinges are glued in and the canopies are attached. Dietrich Models, SD-Models and others have already announced these upgrades as well. I'm sure everyone will follow the Aeroworks lead. Aeroworks planes historically have been heavier than SD-Models, PAU, and QS planes, though they are addressing this. If you want a plane which is easy to build, well engineered and has the best assembly manual in the business, then Aeroworks is the plane for you.
Performance Aircraft Unlimited The aircraft portion of BME is under new ownership. We know the new owner very well and we have great respect for him. We feel that he is a great asset to the company, and we now feel confident in recommending this product line. The name changed from BME airplanes to PERFORMANCE AIRCRAFT UNLIMITED (PAU). Some of the current stock will be sold under the BME name, though as new stock and new items arrive, the name will be converting over to PAU. The 50cc Edge they offer is an excellent plane. It is light in weight and is great for hovering. They offer several planes now, and there are plans for expansion.
NOTE: There is some confusion regarding the name of SD-MODEL produced airplanes. You may know their airplanes which were sold under the following the names:
& AVIATION MODELS & TOC1 & EXTREME FLIGHT
The above names belonged to the US importers who imported SD-Model airplanes. The company in China has always used the US name of SD-Model. Each importer had their own name. Each importer brought planes into the US, and distributed them under their own name. SD-Model simply manufactured planes. They did not market them themselves or put their name on them in the past. These models continue to be imported into the US as they have been for many years. SD Model is a solid company and they will continue to produce planes for the US market for the foreseeable future. TBM has and will continue to offer SD-Model manufactured airplanes. TBM feels that these are currently the best value in an airplane. They have the best combination of price, wing loading, power to weight, flight characteristics, durability, ease of construction, value, quality, workmanship, design, inventory/availability, selection, spare parts, hardware, and tech support. While their competitors may have an edge in one area or another, all in all, I feel that these planes are the best buy when all aspects are considered.
WHICH IS BEST? - All of the planes that we offer fly very well. You will not be disappointed with any of them. If you are primarily interested in 3D flying, then the Yaks are the best. They hover pretty much all by themselves. They fly more slowly due to the large cowl, large fuselage, and thicker wing. The SD-Models 35% Yak has the largest wingspan in its class and the lowest wingloading. If you want to fly with more speed, fly larger maneuvers, and do snaps much more easily, then the Extra's are the best choice. The Extra 260 is a mid wing version of the line of Extra planes, and it has the best pitch and roll coupling of any of the Extras. While the Yaks are extremely stable, they are difficult to snap. The Extra's are less stable and are easy to snap. So, get a Yak for 3D and get an Extra 260 for IMAC.
|